PDA

View Full Version : About LCD, CRT monitors



intssed
01-28-2006, 02:11 AM
I want buy new monitor, but don`t know LCD or CRT monitor better?
Have You any suggestion?

prospector
01-28-2006, 02:33 AM
Went from dual CRTs on all compys to LCDs
would never go back
had all 19" and LCDs are 17 but the realestate that I gave up is quite minor (19 " were 18 viewable) 17s are 17 viewable.
The DESK real estate I GAINED is wonderful, now I can fit a few manuals, my Ring Dings and milk, and my ciggys and a bigger ashtray so I don't have to empty it so often. :D

One thing I've noticed tho is the refresh time, my envisions are 8 ms refresh and the samsungs are 25.

milliseconds don't seem like much but there is a slight delay that I checked when I mixed the brands on the same machine.
the samsungs are behind in the updating on the screen.

but the clarity is great on both compared to a crt

Panikos
01-28-2006, 03:25 AM
Other than space saving I dont like LCDs.
I bought 2 x "LG" LCDs and had them pluged on my Geforce.
The colours were totally wrong. I couldnt see a stepped gradient from black to white compared to crystal clear CRT.

Having wrong monitor is one of the worst scenarios an artist may experience.
I swapped the one LCD with an CRT and recovered my old monitoring system.

LCDs are good for desks, accountants, airports, etc but not for 2D/3D work.

intssed
01-28-2006, 03:26 AM
tnx for your opinion :)

JamesCurtis
01-28-2006, 09:20 PM
One thing good about LCD flat panels is that because the screens are 100% flat you have no distortion of your image at all. Verticals and horizontals are perfect and make lining things up much easier.

EmperorPete
01-29-2006, 10:36 AM
I'm using 2 19" TFT monitors (1 Samsung, 1 Digimate. The Digimate is going back, though, since it's playing up. I'm, replacing it with another Samsung), and I wouldn't go back to CRTs. They are crystal clear (especially using DVI inputs), and the space saving is fantastic. I used to have a big desk with 1 17" CRT and a 21" CRT (I had to move the desk a foot further away from the wall, just to get that beast ON it); I now have a smaller desk (and therefore more space for coffee mugs ;) )

Lightwolf
01-29-2006, 11:10 AM
Well, I just got a new 20" TFT from Samsung... and I wouldn't trade it for a CRT. Colour issues have almost disappeared nowadays, especially if you consider the fact that is it hard to get a high quality CRT - and a decent LCD beats a bad CRT hands down.

Cheers,
Mike
Edit: You should spend a little time setting up the display though, but that goes for CRTs as well.